FLAGLER COUNTY, Fla. – In the world of animal rescue, there are moments that push the boundaries of patience, persistence, and hope.
For Caroline Johnson and the dedicated team at SMART Dog Rescue, one such moment unfolded along the busy I-95 highway near the St. Augustine Outlet Mall.
What began as a frantic call about a scared, malnourished dog in desperate need of help quickly spiraled into a month-long mission, one that would test the limits of their resolve.
The journey began with a sighting of a female dog, alone and trembling on the side of the highway. The call for help was urgent, as the dog, traumatized by past experiences, was in constant danger from the speeding traffic on I-95.
Her fear was palpable, and any attempt to approach her only sent her running further into hiding. This was no ordinary rescue. This was a dog that had been broken by life, and each encounter with humans seemed to deepen her mistrust.
For Caroline, the founder of SMART Dog Rescue, the idea of this dog suffering alone in such peril was unbearable.
Determined to make a difference, Caroline set out on a relentless mission to find and save the dog. Day after day, she drove up and down the highway, hoping to spot her, setting up traps, deploying cameras, and scouring the area for any sign of the dog. Despite her efforts, the elusive pup always managed to slip away, further cementing the fear that had taken root in her heart.
“We worked closely with St. Johns County Animal Control, together had 5 traps set,” said Johnson. “Residents in the community were huge with sightings.”
As the days passed, the situation grew more dire. The dog was growing weaker from lack of food, and every day spent near the highway brought her closer to being struck by a car.
Caroline’s sleepless nights were filled with worries for the dog’s survival, but she refused to give up. Her commitment to the mission was unwavering, her heart fully invested in the rescue, and she knew she had to try everything possible to bring this dog to safety.
After weeks of searching with no success, Caroline decided to focus on a nearby development where the dog had last been spotted.
This time, she wasn’t alone.
Caroline brought along Otis, a gentle and compassionate dog who had helped rescue countless scared, timid dogs in the past. Otis’ warm, social nature had proven to be invaluable when it came to calming frightened dogs, and Caroline believed that with his help, the timid pup might finally find the courage to trust.

With Otis by her side, Caroline took a quiet, patient approach. Sitting calmly in the grass, she kept her presence low and non-threatening, while Otis, on a leash, sat beside her. His calm demeanor set the tone, his natural friendliness gently drawing the fearful dog closer.
For hours, Caroline and Otis waited, letting the dog come to them at her own pace. They knew it would take time; trust, after all, couldn’t be rushed. Finally, after what felt like an eternity, the dog appeared.
At first, she lingered in the distance, watching cautiously. But something had shifted. The welcoming energy from Otis seemed to have worked its magic, and slowly, the dog crept closer, inching her way toward Caroline. Every movement was tentative, every step an act of bravery. Caroline didn’t rush; she remained still, giving the dog the space she needed.
The breakthrough came hours later.
With incredible care, Caroline gently placed a leash over the dog’s head, signaling the success of the mission. The rescue had finally been achieved—a whole month of hard work, countless sleepless nights, and unwavering determination had paid off.
